When interest rates with start going up or if lending standards become more difficult, we often get questions about Seller Financing. In some cases, when a real estate market is down, some sellers may have to to provide some or all of the financing to sell their property.
This article will explore some of the risks of first lien seller financing and second lien seller financing.
First Lien Financing: If the seller finances a portion of the purchase price and there is no prior lien against the property, the lien securing the seller’s loan will be a first lien. There are risks in making any loan; however, the risks of first lien financing are relatively low and can be managed fairly well. With a reasonable down payment, properly prepared loan documents, and title insurance insuring the priority and validity of the lien securing the loan, the risk is reduced substantially. As long as the value of the property does not decrease below the amount of the seller’s loan, taxes are paid, and the property is insured, there is little risk of loss because, upon default, the seller can foreclose the liens securing the loan and re-take title to the property. If the value of the property is not less than the loan amount, no loss should occur.
Second Lien Financing: Second lien financing increases the risk to the seller because the lien securing the loan is secondary to the first lien. That means that the seller has an additional risk; he must ensure that the first lien is paid or risk losing the collateral for his loan. Secondary financing is secured by a lien which is second or inferior to a prior lien against the property. If there is a foreclosure of the first lien, the foreclosure will completely eliminate the collateral for the second lien holder. Consequently, a second lien holder can ill afford a foreclosure of the first lien because it leaves the second lien holder with no collateral. To prevent a first lien from being foreclosed, it is usually necessary to pay the first lien in full or bring the loan current. Assume the sale of a $200,000 home with a commercial lender providing $160,000 (80 percent loan) in financing with seller financing of $20,000 (10 percent). If there is a default in the first lien, the seller will have to either pay the first lien in full or pay the past due amount to prevent foreclosure or risk losing the security for his loan. Assume the monthly payment on the first lien is $1,750 and that the loan is three months in arrears when the seller learns of the default. To avoid losing the collateral for the $20,000 second lien, the minimum the seller would be required to pay is $5,250 (plus any attorney’s fees or collection expenses) to bring the loan current and continue to pay the monthly $1,750 while he attempts to foreclose the second lien.
As you can see, these numbers give the seller a very difficult choice to make: either make a substantial investment to protect his collateral or risk foreclosure of the first lien and the loss of collateral for the second lien.
There are two primary ways the seller can reduce the risk of secondary financing: first, require a substantial down payment by the buyer and second, monitor payments to the first lender by (a) requiring the buyer to sign authorizations required by the first lender to give the seller access to payment information on the first lien; (b) requiring the buyer to provide written evidence each month of payment of the first lien note; or (c) requiring payment of the first lien through a third party trust arrangement. There are practical difficulties with any of these methods but they will provide some level of protection.
If a buyer is interested in requesting seller financing or if a seller is offering seller financing and either party is using a Realtor, you can use a Seller Financing Addendum which will spell out the necessary information required to create the lien.
If you are interested in more information about Seller Financing or want a list of homes for sale in Austin offering seller financing please call us at 512-524-6608.